University of Auckland logo

Stay informed

Receive updates on teaching and learning initiatives and events.

Ed Discussion

Ed Discussion supports these learning types (see definitions):

Collaboration
Discussion

Ed Discussion is an online discussion platform set to replace Piazza as the University’s go-to Q&A tool in 2025. Designed to boost student engagement and foster meaningful interactions within Canvas, it integrates seamlessly within the University’s LMS.

As of 12 December 2024, Ed Discussion was enabled across the institution and training for staff is underway.

How-to guides

Ed Discussion in your Canvas course menu

Ed Discussion is activated by default in your course menu. If you don’t intend to use it for your course, follow these steps to disable it to reduce menu clutter.

  • Navigate to your Canvas course.
  • Click Settings in the course navigation menu.
  • Select the Navigation tab.
  • Drag Ed Discussion from the visible items list to the hidden items.
  • Click Save to apply the changes.

 

Ed Discussion in the Canvas course menu

Guides from the vendor

For setup help, visit the Getting Started guide

* Login is required. Select Australia as your documentation location then enter your University of Auckland staff email address, e.g., username@auckland.ac.nz. You will be sent a login link.

See also:

Using Ed Discussion

Tips and Tricks

 

Ed-Discussion Mobile app

This is a versatile Progressive Web Application (PWA) that can be seamlessly added to your mobile device, functioning just like a native app. Once installed, it offers the same comprehensive features as the desktop version, ensuring a consistent and efficient user experience on the go. For more information on installing the app.

See: Adding Ed Discussion to your Mobile device

Why use Ed Discussion in teaching?

Ed Discussion fosters community and peer learning, promoting active student participation and continuous engagement beyond class hours. It provides a platform for students to reflect on their learning and articulate their understanding.

The tool allows asynchronous interaction through threaded discussions, where you can embed videos, annotate images, upload documents, and use LaTeX for math notation. It also supports collaborative coding in multiple programming languages.

For teaching staff, Ed Discussion centralises questions and discussions, reducing email volume and increasing efficiency. It is highly customisable with categories, tags, and specialised chat rooms, making it easy to organise and manage discussions. Posts can be categorised and set to private or anonymous as needed.

Use it to:

  • Facilitate discussions by creating forums for students to ask questions, share insights, and engage in meaningful dialogue.
  • Enhance collaboration through peer-to-peer interaction and collective problem-solving with collaborative coding and moderated threads.
  • Build community by providing a space for students to reflect on their learning, share ideas, and engage outside of class hours.
  • Track engagement using analytics and reporting to monitor participation and gain insights into student involvement.
  • Provide feedback by highlighting and endorsing correct answers, guiding students towards accurate and valuable information.
  • Organise content with categorised, tagged, and filtered discussion threads for efficient communication.

Piazza vs Ed Discussion vs other tools

Piazza and Ed Discussion are both great for online discussions, but Ed Discussion stands out in a few key areas:

Comparing Piazza and Ed Discussion
Feature Piazza Ed Discussion
User interface Can feel cluttered. Clean, modern interface.
Media integration Supports rich media. Advanced features like embedding videos, annotating images, and using LaTeX for math notation.
Collaboration No collaborative coding. Supports collaborative coding with multiple programming languages.
Customisation Basic categorising and tagging. More options for categorising, tagging, and filtering discussion threads.
Efficiency Centralises questions and discussions, reducing email volume. Centralises questions and discussions, reducing email volume; offers deeper insights into student engagement with analytics and reporting features.
Privacy options Allows posts to be set as private or anonymous. More flexibility in managing privacy settings.

Overall, Ed Discussion enhances the user experience with its modern interface, advanced media integration, and robust collaboration tools, making it a strong successor to Piazza.

Frequently asked questions

Can students use the support email team@edstem.org in case of IT-related issues?

Yes, but it depends on the issue. Most questions are better directed to instructors first. Students rarely face IT issues with Ed Discussion.

Is it possible to select two categories for a post, like related to lecture and lab?

No, only one category can be selected per post to maintain clear organisation in the course.

Is it possible for teachers to opt out of notifications?

Yes, instructors have much more control over notifications. You can customise them through the settings in your account, like opting out of announcements or choosing specific triggers for emails.

Are we able to close threads or categories to responses?

Yes, instructors can lock threads or mark posts as private, preventing further responses.

If you pin a question, is it visible to everyone or just to you?

It is visible to everyone. Pinned posts appear prominently at the top of the thread.

Is there significantly more student engagement with Ed Discussion compared to Piazza or other platforms?

The answer according to the facilitator of an Ed Discussion workshop (who is also a teacher) is, yes. Ed Discussion encourages participation by making it less intimidating for students. The platform integrates Q&A and discussion features more seamlessly, which increases engagement.

Has the increased student engagement been problematic in terms of workload?

The answer according to the facilitator of an Ed Discussion workshop (who is also a teacher) is, not significantly. While there are more questions, they are higher quality and often more interesting. Moderation tools help save time.

When Ed Discussion is embedded within Canvas, it opens in a new tab instead of an iframe. Is there a workaround?

Not really. The full-window experience is preferred, as the iframe can be too cramped.

Can we change the colour border assigned to each course on the dashboard?

No, this is not customisable. It is a feature request currently under consideration.

Can we see who responded "yes" or "no" in a poll? We can only see the summary stats.

No, polls in Ed Discussion are anonymous.

Are there highlightable languages in Ed Discussion for code?

Yes, Ed Discussion automatically highlights code syntax based on the selected language, like Python or SQL.

What is the difference between the 'Code' option in paragraph and 'Code Snippet'?

The “Code” option is plain text, while Code Snippet supports syntax highlighting and is runnable for specific coding languages like Python or SQL.

Can we output all course data, like posts and threads?

Yes, there is a “Download Threads” option that provides data in JSON format, which can be converted into other formats for analysis.

Is there a way to embed an iframe within a post?

Yes, you can embed an iframe within a post using the Web Preview option. This feature allows you to write and preview HTML, CSS, and JavaScript directly. If a specific feature isn’t natively supported by Ed, you can often implement it yourself using custom code in the Web Preview.

Is there a way to block content temporarily so that students cannot view the course discussion, say during a test?

To temporarily block content from students during a test, you can switch the course to “Read Only” in the advanced course settings. This setting prevents new posts or replies but doesn’t hide existing content. Another option is archiving the course, though this is better suited for use after the course ends. Currently, there isn’t a built-in feature to completely hide the discussion board. Removing and re-adding students is a workaround, but it’s a tedious process and not ideal for this use case.

How can we add a post directed to specific students only?

To direct a post to specific students, there is a chat feature available, but instructors cannot create a thread exclusively for a student. Instead, students can create private posts that are visible only to them and the instructor. However, instructors cannot author private posts on behalf of a student.

What is the relevance of 'Anonymous Comments' in settings? It is enabled by default but says 'Not Recommended.'

The ‘Anonymous Comments’ setting allows users to post anonymously on any post. While this feature is enabled by default, it is marked as “Not Recommended” because it removes the ability to control where anonymity is allowed. Users often prefer more granular control over anonymity, which is why this setting isn’t generally advised. However, it can still be used based on your preferences.

What is the relevance of 'Megathread' in Posts & Announcements?

The ‘Megathread’ feature in Posts & Announcements consolidates multiple threads into one. When a post is designated as a megathread, all follow-up comments, particularly top-level ones, are tagged as unresolved by default. This allows for follow-up questions to be asked and resolved within the same thread. It’s a way to manage and streamline discussions by grouping related topics together.

Is there an option for students to remain fully anonymous?

No, ‘Anonymous’ on the discussion board means that a student’s name is hidden from their peers but not from staff. This distinction is clearly noted in the platform.

Are 'tutorials' in Ed Discussion about grouping students?

Tutorials in Ed Discussion could potentially relate to Categories, which can be used to organise discussions and group content by topics or sessions. Categories might serve to group students or discussions specific to tutorial sessions.

Will it be possible to use or set up Ed Discussion on manually created Canvas courses?

Yes, Ed Discussion can be used in manual (non-enrolled) Canvas courses. For example, a manual course for Lab Safety could have Ed Discussion enabled by the course director for student access. It is recommended to review how students are added to such courses, such as using sections with specific start and end dates.

I need to 'Sync with LMS' to add new students/staff added to Canvas. Can we automate this?

Since Ed uses Learning Tools Interoperability (LTI 1.3), the course roster should sync automatically. However, this process will need to be confirmed with the vendor.

If I assign roles like Tutor to TAs, they get reset to Admin when I 'Sync with LMS' again. How can we prevent this?

Using the ‘Sync with LMS’ button restores the original roles from Canvas. This will need to be referred to the vendor to understand when and how the sync button should be used to avoid role resets.

Support

Check out our learning technology support page to find out what options are available for Ed Discussion.

See also

Comparing Piazza, Ed Discussion, and Canvas Discussions

We provide a comparison chart between these popular discussion tools.

University of Melbourne guide

This might help teachers choose the right discussion and chat tools for teaching and learning, depending on context. The guide includes a comparison between Canvas Discussion, Ed Discussion, Microsoft Teams, Zoom Chat and Canvas Chat.

Page updated 30/01/2025 (added FAQs)

Send us your feedback

What do you think about this page? Is there something missing? For enquiries unrelated to this content, please visit the Staff Service Centre

This form is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.